Now that both Part 1 (pasted above) and Part 2 (loaded on Page 25 of the page viewer) are visible, here is the complete combined summary of the FEA findings for tornado resistance and seismic performance:
Wind Pressure & Reinforcement:
Standard ICC 500 Shelter Pressures (250 mph): Typical code wall pressures are 210–265 psf in Exposure C (up to ~320 psf at corners in Exposure D). Every #4 vertical bar spacing studied passes these pressures (the lowest design strength is 366 psf).
Extreme 400 psf Envelope: Meeting the full 400 psf project envelope requires #4 vertical bars at 8 in spacing, which provides 551 psf design strength under inward pressure and 420 psf under outward suction (~417 psf after accounting for cut lap strand edges).
Suction Governs Design: Under inward pressure, the precast skins contribute roughly half of full composite action (0.47 on deflection, 0.55 on moment), stiffening the wall structurally. Under outward suction, the exterior skin goes into tension and the steel laps transfer very little force (0.07 on deflection), making suction the controlling load case.
Panel Width Independence (Part 2): Changing exterior panel widths between 12 in, 24 in, and 36 in has no meaningful impact on wind suction capacity, allowing panel size to be chosen based on casting, handling, and aesthetics.
Tornado & Hurricane Missile Impact:
Zero Perforation: Across all five tested missile scenarios, none perforate the wall or dislodge concrete from the interior face.
15 lb Tornado Missile (100 mph): Reaches the core in all cases and causes localized cracking over 3 to 5 in on the interior face directly behind the impact zone, with no predicted material loss (spalling) for either the barred core or the Helix fiber core. Physical ICC 500 testing is recommended to confirm zero interior spalling.
9 lb Hurricane Missile (50 ft/s): Stops 1.0 in into the exterior skin on a rib, or punches through the pocket shell, crosses the polyiso, and rebounds off the core—leaving the interior face uncracked.
Base Dowel Anchorage: At 400 psf, each #4 base dowel carries ~5,430 lb of tension. A 2 in embedment is insufficient; 7.0 in of epoxy embedment into a slab or footing at least 8.25 in thick (with 9 in unbonded yield length below the base joint) is required.
In-Plane Racking Strength & Ductility:
In a virtual ASTM E72 racking test (8 ft wall, 24 in panels, without hold-down rods), the wall carries 47,800 lb (5,980 lb/ft) at 1.22% drift and retains at least 80% of peak capacity up to 1.9% drift.
Capacity is governed by rocking at the base (resisted by the #4 base dowels and roof dead load), rather than shear failure.
Panel Size Independence: Panel widths of 12 in, 24 in, or 36 in produce virtually identical racking strength.
Failure Sequence & Energy Dissipation:
Controlled Yield Hierarchy: Damage progresses predictably: (1) core cracking at the base joint, (2) #4 base dowel yield, (3) interior skin cracking, (4) exterior panel cracking, (5) lap strand yield near peak load, (6) vertical/horizontal rebar yield, and (7) dowel rupture.
Laps Stay Elastic: The expanded steel laps across the polyiso are not the weak link—the exterior skin slides as a single sheet on the spline planes while the lap strands remain elastic up to ~1.0% drift.
High Damping: Under reversed cyclic loading, the wall provides 31% to 34% equivalent viscous damping between 0.25% and 0.5% drift. Beyond 0.5% drift, performance depends on low-cycle fatigue of the base dowels (either fracturing around the 1% cycle under conservative bounds or shifting damage into the bottom courses of the interior skin).
High-Seismic Site Adequacy SDS} = 1.0g to 1.5g:
Ample Margin: On high-seismic sites, the wall has ample racking strength for any ductile design with $R \ge 2$, story drift does not govern against ASCE 7 limits, and out-of-plane seismic pull forces on the exterior panels are negligible compared to wind suction.
Elastic SDS = 1.5g Exception: Only if a shelter were designed to remain purely elastic R = 1 at an extreme SDS} = 1.5g site would additional base dowel area be needed.
Conventional Rebar Required: Because ESR-3949 restricts Helix-only walls to Seismic Design Categories A–C (and Helix alone provides only 185–257 psf wind capacity), conventional #4 rebar is required for high-seismic (SDC D+) and full tornado-shelter applications.